Op-Ed: I am Not a Feminist
If you are searching for a feminist inside me, then you're looking at the wrong person because I’m sorry, I’m not a feminist. I have tried to become one, but no matter what I've done, I've constantly failed. It’s not that I do not want to be a feminist; it’s just that I simply cannot be one.I know that I talk a lot about gender equality and discrimination against women. I have always tried to raise my voice against even the slightest hint of discrimination. But that is all that I have done – talked.
And so, I am sorry to disappoint you all by saying that I am not a feminist. I apologize for being limited to "slogan feminism"; for letting down thousands of woman and girls who hope and dream of a more egalitarian world. These women include my mother, grandmothers, aunts and sisters. They also include my friends, my female teachers and all the women I know.
I became aware of my position very recently when my teacher was discussing gender based discrimination, particularly against women, in class. According to him, although people give tons and tons of lectures about gender equality, little has been translated in practice, even by women and girls. I must admit I, too, fall into that category of "wanna-be" feminists who are all talk but no action. That is why I want to make my stance clear; I do not want to be called a feminist, at least not until I start to practice what I preach.
There are a few people I know, however, who not only talk but also practice their values in their lives. I have a few friends who aren't afraid to play basketball with boys and who do not shy away from confronting men who harass them in public places. But I cannot do so. Although I may give many excuses like how clumsy I am, or that the boys easily outnumbered me, the bottom line is that I'm scared, scared of the consequences of standing up against them. This is one of the reasons why I consider myself to be a non-feminist in spite of being a woman and believing in gender equality.
A few months ago, I posted a status on Facebook that went, “I don’t want to be defined by my prettiness, but sometimes I don’t mind it either.” Clearly, this shows my desire towards looking good. I usually don’t mind looking shabby on a casual day out, but during a party, I make sure that I look good. This means that looking pretty is important to me. It is becoming more difficult to be indifferent towards the comments I receive about my looks. No matter how hard I try, I find myself influenced by what people say because everyone is increasingly concerned about appearances.
I think that I fall under the category of women who love dressing up to impress, please and probably even make others envious. I don’t have my own view about my dressing style and I can’t even stand for my own style. For example, every time I go out with my family, I either succumb to my mother’s wishes or take support from my brother about how I ought to dress up. My dad teases me saying that I am still not old enough to dress up as I please, in spite of my age. If it is difficult for me to stand up for my own choices within my family, you might be able to imagine how much strength I would require to stir up my society and bring about change.
I remember once one of my uncles said that men and women are equal in all aspects apart from their physical strength. At that time, this got me very angry because I believed that men and women should be equal even with respect to physical strength. I blamed traditional views of a patriarchal society that made sure that women never made it to the top. I derived my hypothesis by trying to discern the historical context that has made men and women so different physically. During the Stone Age, women were restricted to taking care of homes and rearing children while men went out to hunt. This, then, led to women’s body to adapt to work that requires less physical strength. And that’s why, I concluded, women weren't as strong as men.
But now as I reflect on this issue, I realize that men and women are quite different from one another. Women, apart from being physically "weaker", are also more emotional. Men, on the other hand, are far less expressive with their emotions. It seems that men are more ambitious while women tend to focus more on love and relationships. So how can men and women be the same?
To say that men and women are different in some ways, however, does not mean that what they do has to be mutually exclusive. While I might believe in the distribution of domestic chores as well as sharing of financial responsibilities between husband and wife, I have never taken the initiative to mend broken things or buy small daily items or even pay bills which my brother does. I would rather continue to feel lazy and stay at home in my designated work area of the kitchen. My brother hasn’t learnt how to cook dinner and nobody at home forces him to do so. Unlike with me.
My mother comes home from office and goes straight to kitchen because nobody besides her, my grandmother and I cook at home. So how can I be a feminist? Not only do I shy away from stepping into the "manly" duties my brother fulfills, I also continue to participate silently in the discrimination I face at home on a daily basis. I cannot blame my laziness all the time and neither can I blame the ways of my home. I know that I can change if I want to, but the problem is that I don’t feel the need. So how can I be called a feminist?
Until recently I was confused whether to call myself a feminist or not but now I know where I stand. I say that I don’t believe in celebrating woman's day, simply because this day reminds me of our weakness and our need of a day to celebrate our womanhood. The real problem lies in the fact that I cannot do anything alone. All the so called women's rights activists participate on this day in some rally, shouting slogans. They organize different programs that reflect upon the need to uplift women's status in society and hence the importance of women's day. And then they go back home, enter their kitchens and prepare meals for their husbands and children as silent and obedient wives and mothers.
At least I have finally come clean by saying that I am not a feminist, not yet. But believe me I’m trying, trying really hard to become one. I have finally come to the conclusion that instead of searching for similarities between men and women, I’ll move on by accepting and being proud of the differences. Yes, I’m not a feminist yet, but consider this - are you?
Very genuine expressions,thumbs up!!
Well, thank you, both of you. I'll try my very best to keep the momentum for very long and also not to follow the rules that society has imposed. And yes, I'll keep on raising my voice in this issue so I guess I won't be mellowed out. Anyway, thank you once again, for the comments.
I can identify with a few things you've mentioned myself. But you know, wanting to look pretty" is not anti-feminist.There's noting wrong with trying to feel good about yourself. Yes, we as women, a lot of time, seek love and acceptance by being "pretty" but I have come to realize that acceptance and love need to come from myself, towards myself first. And that is why I do the things I do. You should not have to defend yourself for that, Suv :)
ps: as to whether or not you will slowly lapse into yourself, i think the fact that youve realized the situation and have written about it wont let you.
And yes, I am a feminist, but the world's definition of feminist might be different to mine :)
hey alisha,
thanks for that....and you're correct about having own term of feminism.....
nice writing suv ,http://www.psy.fsu.edu/~baumeistertice/goodaboutmen.htm goto this link and read this article if you have time , it might give you some insights in gender equality
that was great suv. i really like it. =)
hi Suv. Good Article. but don't u think u should focus more on other aspects of woman and their power & potential to perform. I am a grown up man but i love cooking and i do help my mom with it as well as cleaning after having food. I don't know weather that makes me a feminist or not but since i am criticizing what u r saying, i guess u'd not like to give me that tag. u can't complain about your mom going inside the kitchen at this age, especially those women who are housewife. that doesn't changes anything. its her or lets say in general, woman's love for the family that drags her to the kitchen floor. The new age ppl won't do it, i know and u know too but the food needs to be cooked anyways and the stomach has to be filled either its mens or womens. and i only wish that there was a stable government first so that we could find a platform for all of us to do what we wish to do. keep up the good work.
Well, hello Shantanu. I knw the country's going through a lot, but I guess being a female species (I think i'm still a girl but many may term me as a woman, so) it occurs to me that i shud raise the voices of those women who have gone unheard. Well, I'm actually happy that you cook yourself and help ur mom around but the fact remains the same- women are expected to the household work. i think i did mentioned in the article that my mom is not a housewife, and even i study. but still, in my home and i'm sure in many others as well, women are supposed to do cooking and stuffs, even if they're a working women. i agree with you that food needs to get cooked, stomachs need to get fulled, but if we all help each other in these aspects then probably i needn't write this article in the 1st place. Anyway, thanks for your criticism, hopefully our country will get better in the future.
Excerpt from Shantanu's comment:
<<< u can't complain about your mom going inside the kitchen at this age, especially those women who are housewife. that doesn't changes anything. its her or lets say in general, woman's love for the family that drags her to the kitchen floor. >>>
i think it is another lame shot at attaching emotional values to pure manual labor like cooking and washing dishes, something that this patriarchal male chauvinist society is way better at i guess. I definitely do not drag myself to the kitchen for the love of my family..although i love them the most. i get dragged there because men are just too lazy to drag themselves to the kitchen so please please do not try to justify this. And, another thing...the fact that you mention you cook and do dishes in your home has to stand out so much just proves my point that when a woman enters a kitchen, it is her love for the family and when a man enters kitchen, he is just going way out of everything and is a feat in itself...society, how do you justify this bullshit!
Thank you.
I for one totally agree with noone gets to.....
hey,
i think you're a feminist through and through ... it's always the idea before the action that counts.
everything you wrote here is so true and relatable to (most) nepali girls - how are we to balance the mixed message being sent to us - especially by the women surrounding us more than the men? we are to study hard, get into good schools, kick start our career, negotiate our salaries etc while making sure to walk pretty (more emphasis was always placed on my "outfit" than my performance at my first grown-up job - by who? by me! by my roommate!) and forever folding ourselves into become a bride-able babe. it doesn't matter what i have accomplished - to the women i know and love, they are bent on seeing me "married and happy". reasoning with them is easier said than done. a pity at that, but it's not impossible. i'm trying, i swear.
again, i think everything you've written here so freaking awesome - i'm so glad you received this platform to share your thoughts, gets others to react and well, what do we know, walk the walk instead of just talk the talk.
will be keeping an eye out for your pieces!
p.s. i've only recently begun to talk back at the idiots that think a small comment, whistling and singing suggesting songs is okay. trust me, if you look them in the eye (and not on the ground) and say "kollai bhanya" they immediately retreat like wet dogs, "hoina, hoina, tapailai hoina". i'm amused by their ability to tease and how unable they are to defend themselves. give it a shot. i swear you'll see these are the gutless of the gutless!
Hey nepaliketi,
thanks for your comments...it means a lot to me...well I understand what are you talking about...I have to the same most of the time....well i'm still trying....and I'm glad that did...well I will definitely take your advice...and hope rest of the females out there will also do...thank you once again...
if you believe that women should have the same equal rights as men, you are a feminist. its as simple as that. everything else is bullshit ideology.
like Timothy Leary said "women who seek to be equal to men lack ambition" .
I think women will rule the world someday ,Hillary Clinton must have thought , I could have ruled the world if it wasn't for that Obama and he didn't even paint the white house black , why he..
Dear Ghumne mech ko andho manche,
I know that for most people, just thinking that women should have the same equal rights as men, makes them a feminist. But for me, sadly just thinking is not enough. There needs to be actions to support the thinking. I hadn't been able to actionify (if there's a word like that) my thoughts so I said that I wasn't a feminist. :)
Dear thoughts,
for me everyone is and should be equal. Ruling has never been my choice. But I like the way you mentioned Ms. Clinton and Mr. Obama there. :)
Do you honestly believe everyone is equal?There are conspicuous differences hai ,on that you will assent.Then the question comes everyone should be equal..
OK equality in humans.Equality in man and women and lets not forget the third gender and the foreigners too and those people from future(southpark bad joke) .Physically humans are not equal hai and cerebrally too that's for sure .So naturally humans are not equal.But we humans have already gone the unnatural way and made all those godforsaken institutions and systems hai.So we can keep them equal in our own unnatural way hai.All we need is power(force). We have to coerce them ,oh yes we have to otherwise there won't be equality hai.On this you might refute me and say No we cannot use force to do that, Dear Suv It is by Power that social institution works mostly the political one works if you have not noticed. Do understand it Suv do understand it ,it is wrong i know but that's how it is. A line is drawn and rules are made and if you transgress you are punished somehow.So if you want equality without power then you need like John Lennon said' Imagine' life without institutions and systems .Until that day comes, all we have in our hands is wretched institutions and systems that binds us .So i hope you did understand a bit about the notion of power .So back to my point it is only by force that your equality can be reached .Either You pull up the people that are down,or pull down the people that are up .Coerce people to your standard and make them stay there and you got your equality .
You might say lets give all equal opportunity ,fair start, OK, lets give them that ,but there won't be a fair end would there then you might say we gave them the start its their fault what happened to them ,OK then we will again end up with inequality ,how odd hai ... i am so talking like ayn rand, i should be talking about women equality but i end up on social equality sorry for that .
About the Female equality movement. You have noticed it to be fairly new hai and do you why it is new because it was mostly with physical force that men were able to subdue women and then came along the systems to make women stay there .If in the past women were physically stronger than male then we could had have a whole different story at our hand hai .In this new age physical strength is off little worth comparably and with women voting rights ,things changed drastically for now leaders could mine a whole new source.The system plays us for chumps.
Everyone is not equal hai well physically and cognitively speaking ,that goes for man and women and (man and man) and (women and women). Should everyone be equal my say on this would be everyone will find their place in this world i guess.
also have you noticed nowadays many women when in inter-caste marriage they write two surname hai bit odd hai reminds me of Arundhati roy line women are to choose between using their husband surname or their fathers that's not much of a choice hai and i guess todays women choose both does that make them twice anti feminist .Also their grand children might end up having a pretty long name hehe i guess women need revolution not evolution here hai ..
Well I do know that physically, intellectually and any other dimensionally no two human beings are equal or alike, but by celebrating that diversity and not discriminating on the basis of that difference is what I am trying to focus on. I know that the "Imagine" world, John Lennon talking about is far from reality but dreams are what make us alive, isn't it??? Accepting the fact that you're different and yet giving equal opportunity is what I believe in. Not only it's about equality, it's about equity as well. I AM A GIRL BUT I DO BELIEVE THAT I CAN CONTRIBUTE IN THE SOCIETY EQUALLY AS MEN DO BUT MAY BE IN MY OWN WAY. this is what i'm trying to say :)







Well said. What you say is pretty interesting. But can you or will you keep the momentum in the long run? How can you be sure that you'll not follow the same rules/mores or will you mellow out in the middle.
Even so, i understand that it takes quite a bit to declare what you've declared. Bravo. I hope you'll not mellow out in the end.