Lost Voices
The other day, my friend and I were discussing the situation in Nepal, about what exactly is wrong with it and what needs to be done to make it the way we think it should be. After about an hour of "discussing," we couldn't come to any fixed conclusion. Is there even any one conclusion to a place that has so many problems? Problems of poverty, illiteracy, politics and not to forget, the mentality of our people. I especially stress the mentality because that is what I think the main problem is. All we do is talk for hours on end about our political situation, even more than our personal lives (this includes me too) - especially when exams are near and we need a break from mental stress. We talk about the country when all else has failed to amuse us.
Now, I'm not a writer nor have I written articles of any significance, but this is a matter near and dear to my heart. So please forgive me if I tend to diverge from the subject at times and that you'll just consider it the mistakes of an impulsive, indulgent youth. Let me start by mentioning the things that my friend and I were talking about.
First, I talked about this web magazine (yes, this magazine right here), about how it was the right step into the future of Nepali youth culture, how this magazine had forayed into a new direction in making people's voices heard and telling stories like never before. We have so many stories to tell - stories of personal struggle, stories of accomplishments, stories of change. Speaking our mind is our birth right, but I don't see many people expressing their thoughts elsewhere. I know that each and every one of us want to be heard, we struggle all our lives to find our own voice, that particular thing that makes us who we are. An inability to express can manifest itself into a degrading attitude towards society. Each time I am in Nepal, I see people wandering aimlessly, young people with no clue as to what they are going to do with their lives. These young guns probably have dreams in their hearts, voices in their dreams and music in their souls but nothing to show for it. I think this is what makes us so sick of our situation and politics. The only voices I can see making any sort of progress is in the music medium.
This is where our second topic of the discussion comes in. Like I said, a significant amount of change we are seeing in Nepal is in its music. Now, I'm not talking about those cliche commercial songs that most of you listen to, what I am talking about is the underground music scene of Kathmandu. There are many bands emerging from this scene, not to mention the fusion of genres that we can say belongs solely to our culture. Recently, E.Quals competed for the 'Global Battle of the Bands' competition and did very well (being placed 6th out of 21 countries is a BIG deal!). I'm sure they'll do great in the future. I myself have several old school friends playing in bands that are very well off. I'm not going to name them personally but I take this as an oppurtunity to say that they have brought about (knowingly or not) a change in the music system of our country. Each and every one in this underground music scene are doing what they believe in. They have found their voice! They know what needs to be done and are doing it without a care in the world. But what about the other voices? The voices of art, voices of literature, voices of culture, voices of fashion even. Where have they faded? Or have they yet to be heard? I think that there are still many dreams that have not yet been tapped.
The famous literature of Bhanubhakta, Laxmi Prasad Devkota and others have become bygones, only fulfilling their duties as curricular syllabi. They were great, they even managed to stir up conventional Nepali thinking. But what about now? All their voices seem as lost as we are. I'm sure that when we are older and tired of doing our 12 hour jobs, we will eventually listen to our hearts and do what needs to be done to fulfill our dreams. And it does take some people longer to realize this than others, and that is fine. But even that youthful indulgence is not present anymore.
The last topic that we discussed was opportunities. My friend tells me that Nepal is the way it is because there aren't a lot of opportunities for people to do what they want- be it financial, social or individual opportunities. No arguments there but what have we done lately? There are very few among us who have actually gone out there and made a change to give us that opportunity. And that's when my friends and I realized, we cannot just sit back and complain that there are no opportunities in Nepal while we go abroad and live our lives working our asses off. The developed countries are what they are because of people that go the distance to create those conditions. We need those kinds of people in Nepal: people who believe in what they want to do and believe that they have something new to offer to the community, to the culture, to the system. Even the politicians we hate so much are atleast out there doing something for a cause. Now, our country can be a democratic one, a republic or even under totalitarian rule, but we cannot afford to just sit and discuss while our country tears itself apart. We need to wake up and do something. It doesn't have to be for the betterment of our country. I hope I don't sound like I'm promoting narcissism when I say that you have to do whatever your heart desires - without a care in the world. After all, creativity gives rise to youth culture and revolution is born from this culture, and who knows? This revolution might be just what we need.
P.S.: Of course, I would be just another hypocrite if I didn't practice what I preach. Which is why I plan to come back to Nepal immediately after I finish my B.E. to work on a graphic novel that has been on my mind for quite some time now.
great weldone and love you
"The famous literature of Bhanubhakta, Laxmi Prasad Devkota and others have become bygones, only fulfilling their duties as curricular syllabi.."
Damn straight! You really should write more. And, I am in line to see your graphic novel. I too am a super fan of the art. Cheers.
Love you too dad
Hey Emanuel,
I have a good little story to share too.I live in a decent spread house and hence have to be on my toes all the time.Burglars have to do justice to their occupation.Instead of blaming them for sneaking into my apartment,my family members should be careful to thwart them.The same applies If i lose my iphone at a department store while I am out for shopping groceries.Its no point painting the town red when I should have been more careful with my belongings.
My point is instead of blaming international interference, our leaders should atleast stand united on issues of National Integrity.This is a fundamental principle of Leadership.International politics has always had the policy of "Big fish tries to eat small Fish".This did not end with the end of the cold war between US and the Soviet union nor the end of the Fuhrer(Germany).
The silliest paradox is Nepal hasn't succumbed to international powers in its history.Its leaders have always.
an inspiring read..shows that u r among the few who care.
sumit: i so agree to wat u have said in the end.that's quite a thought!
Hi Emanuel,
You loved reading your article. Although I agree with some of your observations about Nepal and "development" I disagree on others.
First, let me share a historical fact: The idea of "progress" and "development" were introduced (by various reasons) in the Western world around the era of enlightenment (when science became socially appealing and powerful), capitalism economic (the era of mass production; the era of monetary economy) and liberal politics (French & American revolution).
But this same idea of "progress" & "development" as we know them today were introduced to other non-western countries (like Nepal, India & so on) after the wave of global de-colonization (the East India company, French colonies in Africa, and so on).
So, if we look at these historic facts, its pretty clear that the idea of "progress" and "development” as we know them now are not something "natural" but a historic product.
The purpose of saying this is that when we try to see Nepal is the same position as western nations, there is this historic inexperience that Nepal lacks: colonialism. The purpose of colonialism at the face value seems like domination upon another human race, but in essence it was to fulfill economic needs of the then Western societies (mostly free labor as slaves, pristine raw materials, and so on).
So, whilst speaking about Nepal (who was gradually opened to the world only after 1950s) I think we need to be cautious about what development means to us, and what the roles of youths can be. I am 110 percent sure that we can never be as UK or US because Nepal does not share the same historic path; we do not share the same "mentality" of these western societies. And its not that I am being pessimistic; its just a fact. And thank god "we don't have mass blood in our hands with the prosperity".
Bikram
Hi again Emanuel,
It is easy to comment & criticise when what we want is a solution. Well about Nepal's socio-political issue I think it is highly complex. First we have a system that was handed down from oligarchs. Then we have "democracy" which means that decisions cannot be made on coercion. We also have such diversity in our populations - most of whom were historically exploited (like colonials) and discriminated by the dominant forces.We also have our economic / trade difficulties.
But I think these are tiny to a problem so severe and nasty that we don't even realise that we have it. The misconception or misguided notion about "development". What comes to our minds when we think about that? Skyscrapers? Millions of cars polluting our atmosphere? People with lots of money in their pockets / bank accounts? Happy faces ~ Unhappy hearts? Or simply peaceful existence?
I think we youths need to re examine what "development" means for us. It cannot be just copied and pasted into our world.
Let's discuss that.
And about music: I too love music; it’s a part of my life. I loved it when Pat Martino in an interview explained that the separation of consonance and dissonance in music is futile. And when a speaker in TED Talks linked Indian music's lack of harmony to their Hindu mythical mentality.
I would suggest you to go to that link and watch the presentations. Here is the link: http://www.ted.com/
I have "over-used" my space of commentary. I do not intend to offend anyone. Its just ideas that came to my mind after reading your observation about Nepal. Comments and clarifications are welcome.
Bikram
Hi Bikram,
I don't know about me but I can see that you'd certainly love reading your comments.
And anyways, what is it that you do not agree about what I say? I used the example of development of music in our country as a way to show that we are making progress as a whole in that front. And that we need to make the same kind of progress in the other areas as well. While i do agree on your "development as we know are not something natural but a historic product" view, I think that it has its limits in its own way. Because then whatever chance that we had for development is gone because historically speaking, we did not take the colonialism path.
And you are entitled to your opinion but when have I ever said that we need to emulate the thinking of the foreign countries?? Yes, we youths do need to re-examine what developement means to us man, and to me that means liberating ourselves artistically.
Nice positive article. I also came back home recently after finishing my studies. I hope to engage myself constructively. You are right, sadly we hardly have an appreciation for the arts. We don't even really have a proper department or school dedicated to the arts. There's medicine, engineering, management but no real good university for arts.
As for music, I can definitely agree that music is something that unites Nepal. Look at Kutumba doing amazing work. They've been travelling all over surrouding areas in Kathmandu and beyond promoting, playing traditional Nepali instrumental songs where community members throng the streets to watch. They'll be in the US later this month as part of a tour. That will be good publicity for Nepal. Look forward to reading your graphic novel.







Really loved the topics u discussed.... n some parts were like the words wht i generally think...loved it