Blog

Borders Create Strangers

Let’s talk frankly about India. We hate Indians. We hate them with a passion reserved for no one else. We hate their accents, their clothes, their sensibilities, their pride, their nationalism, their people, everything about them. If an Indian happens to say something remotely derogatory towards Nepal, we burst out into the streets, tires blazing and flags unfurled. When our VP took his oath in Hindi, we ganged up, scapegoating him, blaming him and the Indians for everything wrong with our country.

So why this unrivalled hatred for India? Is it because they’re bigger, stronger and better than us? Or is it because they meddle in our affairs and practically own some of our politicians? Or is it because, without India, Nepal would be nothing.

Think about it. How much of our goods and supplies comes in from India? How much of our borders touch India? If India decided suddenly to impose sanctions on Nepal, what would happen to us? No food, no fuel, no clothes, no money. What if the Indians decided to take umbrage at our constant derogatory remarks about them and decided to have their own riots? What if they decided to turn on every Nepali in India? Or what if the Indians closed off our open border?

Our economy is in shambles. Does anyone wonder why our money is still worth something? We have a barely functioning economy. Investors are leaving in droves and no one wants anything to do with Nepal. How can anyone run an industry or a business with power cuts for 16 hours a day? Add to that the constant threat of militant unionism. The only reason why our currency is as strong as it is, is because of India and how our money is pegged to theirs. Remember the NRS 1.60=IRS 1?

We watch their movies, ogle at their actresses and marvel at their cricket team. We can even speak their language. We are so steeped in Indian culture that it is almost a knee-jerk reaction to dislike them, hate them even. They’re the big wigs in South Asia. It’s not just us. Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, you can find anti-Indian sentiments everywhere. But what we forget is that borders are arbitrary. In and of themselves, borders have no meaning. They don’t exist naturally. Countries didn’t exist when the world was formed. We made them, we created them and we gave them the potent meaning that they now hold.

What I propose is radical. It’s almost unthinkable. But it’s so crazy that it just might work. How about we…don’t hate Indians? How about we don’t separate ourselves according to country or region? We’ve done away with racism, discrimination and castes. Why it is so hard to get rid our hatred for India? Sure, they meddle, they poke and prod. But does our dislike need to boil down to the level of using epithets and insults? Sure, there’s hegemony involved, and there are ways to oppose that. Why must we always, always lower ourselves? We riot, we fight and we hurl insults like rocks. It’s time we did away with foolish jingoism and blind hatred.

Love your neighbor. Borders create strangers.

Nishant ( Jul 2nd 2009, 01:02 PM ) says:

Finally, a sane voice on the rampant anti-India sentiment in Nepal. Great work.

Two quotes on human nature and nationalism:-

"In the imagination of the simple patriot the nation is not a society but Society. Though its values are relative they appear, from his naive perspective, to be absolute"- Reinhold Niebuhr, Moral Man and Immoral Society

"Carrying their idols before them, the nationalistic masses of our time meet in the international arena, each group convinced that it executes the mandate of history, that it does for humanity what it seems to do for itself, and that it fulfills a sacred mission ordained by Providence, however defined. Little do they know that they meet under an empty sky from which the gods have disappeared"- Hans Morgenthau, Politics among nations

pranaya.rana ( Jul 3rd 2009, 12:44 AM ) says:

you might also want to check out benedict anderson's imagined communities. its a good read on how nations and countries are formed and the loyalties they inspire.

Aditi ( Jul 4th 2009, 11:27 AM ) says:

Nice one Pranaya. Really, we Nepalis hate India (and Indians so much) becaude despite being so much like us, they are so much better than us. Our ineriority makes us hateful. We should do away with it, seriously.

shristi ( Sep 29th 2010, 11:36 AM ) says:

First of all I want to say that Pranaya, i really like your write ups. I think they are original and to a certain extent free from bias(a personal opinion however can never be neutral).

Now about this article, I understand where you are coming from and to a certain extent I understand the blind hatred fixated in people's minds.

However, I will tell you a true account. On my way to a borderland, which was a no man's land before few years, I came across many Indians who just a month ahead were actually Nepalis.

They were badly bruised, beaten up by Indian security forces , t heir houses burnt and sons taken away for interrogation, but never returned.

This makes me hate India. This makes me advocate for the rights of these people who are Nepali in heart but not on the map. I would share the same feeling of mutual benefits and what not if India also had given us the respect. the respect we deserve and not what we beg for.

I do love Indian culture and heritage and music. About people I have mixed feeling but also due to experience and not ignorance. But more than that I love Nepal, my country of staggering economy and dependent mentality, poor people both financially and psychologically. I love Nepal for I see her for much more than the handicaps.

I hate India for their lack of respect towards us and I hate the mentality of Nepali people that "they" (irrespective of whatever nation) are better than us.

If this makes me full of illusion, so be it.

alisha ( Jun 14th 2011, 11:37 AM ) says:

This has, in a way,got nothing do with what you've written but has more to do with the topic itself. I do agree with what youve said,but I cant help but express my opinion about this:

I dont hate Indians but I definately hate the Indian politics that has continously screwed up our country. Of course I realize Nepali politicians are equally as pathetic for letting them do so. But when is this going to stop?I mean how sad is it that a country which is the second richest in the world in terms of water resources cant generate electricity from its rivers because its neighbouring country doesnt allow it? And the fact that thousands of Nepalese have been displaced from their own homes due to Indian security forces, the fact that hundreds of women (some as young as our 9 year old cousins and some as old as our grandmothers) get raped and abused by these men makes me so so angry.

I realize that India as a whole country isnt to be blamed for this but I have to say, if this kind of behaviour, abuse and manipulation of our people and politics continues, the country will be bringing the hatred upon itself.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <div> <p> <hr>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options


Mollom CAPTCHA (play audio CAPTCHA)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.